Academic behaviour and university policy: evaluation as a tool to change researchers’ behaviour in Italy and UK

Leiden Repository

Academic behaviour and university policy: evaluation as a tool to change researchers’ behaviour in Italy and UK

Type: Article in monograph or in proceedings
Title: Academic behaviour and university policy: evaluation as a tool to change researchers’ behaviour in Italy and UK
Author: Cardi A.Derrick G.
Journal Title: STI 2018 Conference Proceedings
Start Page: 184
End Page: 188
Publisher: Centre for Science and Technology Studies (CWTS)
Issue Date: 2018-09-11
Keywords: Scientometrics
Abstract: This study provides a comparison of the post-evaluation effects of national research evaluation frameworks in the UK and Italy at university (macro) and researcher (micro) level. We compare how universities and researchers have responded to their evaluation frameworks, within the constraints of each university system and culture. The study draws on the policies informing the operationalisation of the UK’s Research Excellence Framework (REF) and Italy’s Valutazione della Qualità della Ricerca (VQR). We compare the national approaches to evaluation by analysing the purposes, the real use of outputs, the criticism, and effects of the respective evaluation exercises. This paper discusses these effects as part of a wider approach to influencing university and researchers’ outcomes towards desirable goals. With data collected via semi-structured interviews we explore how evaluation is used to drive research actors in desirable directions. With the review of literature surrounding the effects of evaluations on the national (mega), university (macro) and researcher (micro) levels and their integration, we explore the intertwined implications for the decisional system, the organizational structures, and the individual performance. Under this perspective we look at evaluation as a technique used to influence behaviour at the macro and micro research level. Comparing post-evaluation effects of different frameworks in different context allows, on one hand, identifying some specific country/culture related aspects. On the other, it allows identifying new understandings of how auditing research productivity by altering behaviours on macro and micro level, ingenerates intentional and unintentional changes at all levels.
Handle: http://hdl.handle.net/1887/65232
 

Files in this item

Description Size View
application/pdf STI2018_paper_40.pdf 4.959Mb View/Open

This item appears in the following Collection(s)