On the determinants and consequences of punishment goals : power, distrust, and rule compliance

Leiden Repository

On the determinants and consequences of punishment goals : power, distrust, and rule compliance

Type: Doctoral Thesis
Title: On the determinants and consequences of punishment goals : power, distrust, and rule compliance
Author: Mooijman, M.
Journal Title: Dissertatiereeks, Kurt Lewin Institute
Issue Date: 2016-06-14
Keywords: Punishment goals
Power
Distrust
Rule compliance
Abstract: This dissertation focuses on the determinants and consequences of leaders’ punishment goals. I investigate how and why leaders rely on certain punishment goals, and how and why leaders’ reliance on such punishment goals affects punishment effectiveness. Specifically, in this dissertation I demonstrate that—with increasing power over others—leaders rely more on punishment goals that are suboptimal in promoting rule compliance. I demonstrate that power fosters a distrustful mindset towards people, which increases reliance on deterrence—but not just deserts as a punishment goal. Using deterrence—as opposed to just deserts—as a justification for punishments, in turn, decreases people’s willingness to comply with rules because people feel distrusted by the leader. Finally, leaders' reliance on suboptimal punishment goals can be explained by their motivation to maintain power over others. Although power may thus increase leaders’ reliance on punishments to deter rule-breaking behavior, paradoxically, this may at times decrease the effectiveness of the punishment.
Promotor: Supervisors: E. van Dijk; W. W. van Dijk; N. Ellemers
Faculty: Social and Behavioural Sciences
University: Leiden
Uri: urn:isbn:9789402801620
Handle: http://hdl.handle.net/1887/40167
 

Files in this item

Description Size View
application/pdf Full text 1.204Mb View/Open
application/pdf Title page_Contents 280.4Kb View/Open
application/pdf Chapter 1 Introduction 312.1Kb View/Open
application/pdf Chapter 2 524.7Kb View/Open Full text at publisher site
application/pdf Chapter 3 330.3Kb View/Open
application/pdf Chapter 4 390.8Kb View/Open
application/pdf Chapter 5 287.7Kb View/Open
application/pdf References 317.8Kb View/Open
application/pdf Summary in Dutch 215.4Kb View/Open
application/pdf Acknowledgements_Curriculum Vitae 228.1Kb View/Open
application/pdf Series information 228.2Kb View/Open
application/pdf Propositions 98.11Kb View/Open

This item appears in the following Collection(s)